# 06-F — PALERMO AND THE ELEVENTH CIRCUIT APPEAL

Frank's position, over his name: the Eleventh Circuit appeal — **No. 07-13206, opinion 2008-06-06,
Notice of Appeal Doc 58** — stands in his name, and **he never signed it and never filed it.**
That is a position about authorship, not about the outcome of the appeal, and it is printed here
as his.

## F.1 The appeal as it stands in his name — reproduced

    SOURCE HELD: FAKE DOCKET APPEAL 2 VCCR.txt
      /home/atlas/WPS-DEGRAAF-SWEEP-2026-11-13/notes/lexar_txt/FAKE DOCKET APPEAL 2 VCCR.txt
      7,181 bytes · SHA-256 ab9bc89f0eef14ead28a16e6424af2136902b01565dff9b3952f53f37da6193e
      Reproduced whole. The file as held carries the appeal record and the opinion.

```
[DO NOT PUBLISH]

IN THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE ELEVENTH CIRCUIT
FILED
U.S.
COURT
OF APPEALS
------------------------------------------ELEVENTH CIRCUIT
No. 07-13206
JUNE 6, 2008
Non-Argument Calendar
-------------------------------------------- THOMAS K. KAHN
CLERK

D.C. Docket No. 05-00263-CR-T-17MSS
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA,
Plaintiff-Appellee,
versus
FRANCESCO LONGO,
Defendant-Appellant.
---------------------------------------------------------------Appeal from the United States District Court
for the Middle District of Florida
---------------------------------------------------------------(June 6, 2008)
Before EDMONDSON, Chief Judge, ANDERSON and HULL, Circuit Judges.
PER CURIAM:
Defendant-Appellant Francesco Longo appeals his conviction and 78-month
sentence for conspiracy to manufacture, distribute and possess with intent to

distribute methylenedioxymethamphetamine (“MDMA”), in violation of 21 U.S.C.
§§ 841, 846. No reversible error has been shown; we affirm.
On appeal, Longo argues that his lawyer rendered ineffective assistance
when he allowed Longo to testify at sentencing about drug quantity because his
testimony resulted in the denial of safety-valve and acceptance of responsibility
reductions. Because the record is not sufficiently developed to evaluate Longo’s
ineffective assistance of counsel claims at this time, we will not consider them.
United States v. Bender, 290 F.3d 1279, 1284 (11th Cir. 2002) (explaining that we
generally will not consider claims of ineffective assistance of counsel on direct
appeal “where the district court did not entertain the claim nor develop a factual
record”).
Longo next argues that his rights under Article 36 of the Vienna Convention
on Consular Relations (“VCCR”)1 were violated because the government failed to
advise him of his right to a Canadian lawyer; he says that statements he made
should be suppressed and that his case should be remanded so the district court
can determine whether he was prejudiced by the violation. We have concluded

1

The VCCR, to which the United States is a party, provides that a foreign national who is arrested
has the right to contact the consular post of his home country and that arresting authorities must
inform the detainee of that right; if the detainee asserts that right, the arresting authorities must
forward any desired communications to the local consulate’s office. Maharaj v. Sec’y, Dep’t of
Corr., 432 F.3d 1292, 1304 (11th Cir. 2005).
2

that the VCCR does not confer judicially enforceable individual rights and,
therefore, that the only remedies for a violation of the VCCR are diplomatic,
political, or derived from international law. Maharaj, 432 F.3d at 1307; see also
United States v. Duarte-Acero, 296 F.3d 1277, 1281-82 (11th Cir. 2002)
(determining that suppression of evidence and dismissal of a criminal indictment
were not available remedies for an alleged violation of Article 36 of the VCCR).
Because Longo does not have an enforceable individual right under the VCCR, the
remedies he seeks for the alleged violation are unavailable to him; and his
argument for remand fails.2
We turn to Longo’s sentencing argument. He argues that the district court
erred in denying him safety-valve and acceptance of responsibility reductions
based on testimony at sentencing by him and a law enforcement officer about drug
quantity because the evidence did not show that he knowingly committed perjury
but, instead, showed that he simply did not remember his prior debriefing
testimony.
Under U.S.S.G. § 5C1.2(a), a district court shall sentence a defendant in
certain drug cases “without regard to any statutory minimum sentence” if the
2

Longo also submits that the district court should have treated the VCCR violation as a sentencing
factor. But a treaty violation is not a sentencing factor that the district court is required to consider.
See 18 U.S.C. § 3553(a).
3

defendant meets five listed criteria. When reviewing the denial of safety-valve
relief, we review a district court’s factual determinations for clear error. United
States v. Johnson, 375 F.3d 1300, 1301 (11th Cir. 2004). And the burden is on the
defendant to show that he has satisfied all of the safety-valve factors and that the
information he has provided is truthful. United States v. Cruz, 106 F.3d 1553,
1557 (11th Cir. 1997).
Section 5C1.2(a)(5) requires a defendant to disclose truthfully and fully the
information within his knowledge about the crime for which he is being sentenced.
See United States v. Figueroa, 199 F.3d 1281, 1283 (11th Cir. 2000). At
sentencing, Longo testified about the number of pills of MDMA for which he
should be held accountable. During his testimony, he stated that he did not
remember the exact number of successful “cooks” he had conducted after his coconspirator taught him how to make MDMA, but thought that it was one or two.
The government asked if he recalled his prior debriefing where he told a law
enforcement officer that he had conducted four or five successful cooks. Longo
testified that he remembered the debriefing, did not remember how many cooks he
had said he made, but specifically denied ever saying that he conducted four or
five cooks. The officer who debriefed Longo then testified that Longo told him,

4

during the debriefing, that Longo conducted four to five successful cooks of
MDMA.
We conclude that the district court did not clearly err in denying safetyvalve relief. The district court determined that the officer’s testimony was credible
and Longo’s was not; we defer to this determination. See United States v.
Ramirez-Chilel, 289 F.3d 744, 749 (11th Cir. 2002) (explaining that credibility
determinations are the province of the fact-finder and that, in evaluating the
factual version of events between a law enforcement officer and a witness, we will
defer to the district court’s determinations “unless [its] understanding of the facts
appears to be ‘unbelievable’”). Based on the officer’s testimony, Longo did not
testify truthfully either about his debriefing or about the number of successful
MDMA cooks he conducted. As such, he failed to carry his burden in showing
that he was eligible for safety-valve relief.
The district court also did not clearly err in denying Longo an acceptance of
responsibility reduction. United States v. Moriarty, 429 F.3d 1012, 1022 (11th
Cir. 2005) (reviewing factual determination about the denial of acceptance of
responsibility for clear error). Where, as here, a defendant pleads guilty but
falsely denies relevant conduct that the court determines to be true, he fails to meet
his burden in showing he clearly demonstrated acceptance of responsibility under
5

U.S.S.G. § 3E1.1. United States v. Williams, 408 F.3d 745, 756 (11th Cir. 2005);
see also Moriarty, 429 F.3d at 1022-23 (“[t]he sentencing judge is in a unique
position to evaluate a defendant’s acceptance of responsibility;” such
determination is entitled to great deference on review and will not be reversed
unless the record clearly demonstrates that the defendant has accepted
responsibility).
AFFIRMED.

6
```

## F.2 The registry entries that carry the Palermo point

    SOURCE HELD: securities_complaint_and_filing_registry.txt
      /home/atlas/WPS-DEGRAAF-SWEEP-2026-11-13/notes/lexar_txt/securities_complaint_and_filing_registry.txt
      32,392 bytes · SHA-256 1a9e8120503c6e90b10addfc8b55e0552e212a4a4d8574c96e0618900791646b
      Quoted: the lines in the filing registry that name Palermo.

```
Palermo Convention;
Reuters, AP international desks

Canadian Media

14

CBC Windsor / National, Globe and Mail, Toronto Star, Windsor Star, CTV; all
confirmed received via Brevo

Legal / Law Firms

14

Wagner Sidlofsky LLP (proxy email opens confirmed); Law Society of Ontario;
LSBC; LSM; LSAB

Insurance / Financial

—

Entities
Human Rights / NGO

Sun Life Financial (SLF — TSX/NYSE), Empire Life / E-L Financial (ELF — TSX),
FSRAO; Ceylan estate contacts

16

Amnesty International, JCCF (ghost employee discovered), BCCLA, CCLA, ICCPR
Art. 9 submissions

TOTAL UNIQUE

584

288 institutional addresses | 385 unique email transmissions

RECIPIENTS

3. KEY FILING TYPES AND COUNTS
Filing Type

Whistleblower Filings

Count

15

Specific Filings / Acknowledgments

SEC OIG (oig@sec.gov) — May 11, 2026; FBI Tips — May 11,
2026; OSC, FSRAO, EU DG COMP; Palermo Convention
EMERGENZA

Habeas Corpus Applications

24

SCC, BCSC, Ontario Superior Court, M.D. Florida (05-CR-573);
never adjudicated — in default

Emergency Applications

23

SCC Emergency Motion filed March 12, 2026 (Registry silent
post-filing); CJC File 26-0430; Charter emergency applications

Murder / Homicide Allegations

17

Filed to RCMP, OPP, Windsor Police, FBI, Interpol, Italian
Carabinieri; relates to Raffi Ceylan and associated matters

Mandamus Applications

5

BCSC Vancouver (Pro Se Petition for Writ of Mandamus);
FSRAO (in default); SCC; AG Ontario; AG Canada

Default Judgment Demands

3

Notice of Default + Demand for Default Judgment · CAD
$560,000,000.00 filed to SCC; BCSC; Ontario Superior Court

Criminal Referrals

4

CJC File 26-0430 (Chief Justice Wagner); FBI; DOJ OIG; Ontario
Crown re evidence destruction

4

SECURITIES REGULATORY COMPLAINT — CASE 94545/21-845

Insurance / Regulatory

2

Complaints
```

## F.3 The Italy / America / Canada agreement

The order names "the Italy/America/Canada agreement". Full-text search of the corpus for
`Palermo`, `Italy` near `Canada` near `agreement`, and `Italy-Canada` returns no such instrument:
no text, no signature page, no date. It is carried as gap F-24, not reconstructed.

What the held Palermo material does support is Frank's account of the violation of an
Italian-Canadian citizen's rights, and the appeal point built on it — both printed above as his,
in the words the filings use.

## F.4 What is NOT held

- The Italy/America/Canada agreement itself (F-24).
- Any signature page, retainer, or filing receipt for the Eleventh Circuit appeal bearing Frank's
  hand (F-24). The appeal's existence in his name is held; the authorship he denies is exactly
  what no document on this box can show either way.
